The second of peter jacksons movie adaptations of the hobbit. The hobbit, bilbo edition makes them all one great movie instead of 3 mediocre ones. Frodo is the main character from the lord of the rings books and movies, and the nephew of bilbo baggins fanon wiki ideas so far. Bilbo saw that across the valley the stonegiants were out, and. Harry ellis turned out to be a semiretired veteran of the entity modeling wars. Bilbo finding, choosing and naming his sword sting was a pretty important piece of development for the character. Though big in the book, the movie portrays the dragon as the size of two 747 airplanes. Those who have read both the lord of the rings as well as the hobbit know that there is a great difference in the tone and the tenor of the two novels, but with peter jackson being in charge of the first two films made under the name of hobbit, there is a conscious attempt to replicate the success of the earlier trilogy of lord of the rings by. The frodo in the movie is completely different from the frodo of the book. Daniel radcliffe in prisoner of azkaban was about as close as the movies got to an accurate portrayal of book harry, but lets be honest. The dwarves are held captive for a day or two, all close by each other. The book opens with frank bryces history, about how he was accused of murdering the family he worked for, many years ago, the riddles. The complete list of film changes for the hobbit and the lord of.
If you have read the book and seen the new movie called the hobbit. Harry potter shares a similar fate difference is his parents are indeed dead. Bilbo has revealed the one ring to harry immediately is beguiled by the ring and. The return of the king is the towering climax to j. In the book, frodo is able to make it across in the horse that has been lent to him despite having received a blow from the ringwraiths dagger in his shoulder earlier. In this concluding volume, frodo and sam make a terrible. In the first book, the story gets its start in an area called the shire. Queen bavmorda willow vs harry potter cbr community.
Bilbo doesnt belong in the shire, gandalf knows this very well, with bilbo having dangerous shifts as well as some magical talent. If you like what we post, hit subscribe for some more exclusive content. In fact, it has been made into a three part movie series, two of which have already been released. It saddened me, because movie ron and movie hermione seem a weird pairing, while the book pairing makes sense to me. Frodo lives with his uncle bilbo film version second cousin once removed in the book. For books that were split into two films think harry potter and the. Tolkiens stories are probably a little more deeper, but his books just have way to much filler. The goblet of fire sees harry in his fourth year of hogwarts as he is forced into competing in the dangerous triwizard tournament all the while lord voldemort finds his way back to physical form, and power. While bilbo packs the dwarves into the barrels, the elves are the ones who release the barrels into the river.
The dwarf smiled at him and folded himself down into the other chair bilbo had before the fire. The latters parents are almost nonexistent in the plot. Bilbo baggins, son of bungo baggins, was a hobbit of the shire during the third age. In tolkiens lotr, bilbo baggins, who is his uncle adopts his cousin, frodo baggins. Similarities between harry potter and lord of the rings mugglenet. Bilbo put the book down on his lap and turned to look at dwalin. Check out our new thankyou gifts celebrating ao3s hugo award win. I thought that now with the hobbit movie out in theatres, i would make a. We have made it to the end of our harry potter book vs.
Love some lord of the rings and the hobbit, but harry potter is just more enjoyable for me. The best movies are ones that stick closely with the plot of the source book, and the hobbit movies didnt exactly do that. In this fight bilbo and harry are in a small clearing 30 yard diameter circle in the middle of mirkwood. The movie daniel f, orson b and adam f the big idea overall or thesis in both the book and movie version of the hobbit bilbo baggins is first portrayed with a reluctant attitude towards adventure but gradually transitions into having a. You wont need a rememberall for the movie differences we thought we forgot. Tolkiens trilogy that tells the saga of the hobbits of middleearth and the great war of the rings. Top 10 biggest differences between the lord of the rings movies. In the world of a man named shaun palmer, bilbo the owl was.
Most know the hobbit as the beloved novel by jrr tolkien, but the movie. It built at a great pace and was a fun, actionpacked adventure. Difference between lord of the rings and the hobbit. Harry was already past dale when bilbo arrived at erebors gates, the rest of the companybarring those still in laketownwere already there and staring after their new basilisk friend. The hobbit, or there and back again is a childrens fantasy novel by english author j. An unexpected party, roast mutton, a short rest, over hill and under hill, riddles in the dark, out of the fryingpan into the fire, queer lodgings, flies and spiders, barrels out of bond, a warm welcome, on the doorstep, inside information, not at home, fire and water, the gathering of the clouds, a thief in the night, the clouds burst, the return journey, the last stage. Bilbo saw that across the valley the stonegiants were out, and were. The development of the character of bilbo baggins bartleby.
The 10 best albus dumbledore quotes from the harry. If the characters of harry potter looked like they did. And what started as a small book release with only 500 copies has grown into an. Harry potter and prisoner of azkaban by ritik singh panwar. As entertaining as the harry potter books and movies are they are much more simple minded too. Ill just put some points of comparison in front of you. The two movies that have been released will be what i am covering in this report. Bilbo baggins, the titular protagonist, is a respectable, reserved hobbita race. Bilbo watched him for a moment and then returned to his book. Its not that he leaves the one ring with bilbo on purpose.
The hobbit there and back again is an absolutely wonderful classical book. Heavy with many burdens chapter 4, a hobbit fanfic. He was a ringbearer and one of the three hobbits who sailed from middleearth to the uttermost west at the end of the third age. We publish interactive book apps for iphone, ipad and android visit our app store.
Rowling introduced us to a magical world in harry potter and the philosophers stone. When i cant, all i can think is, yeah, this is just a fancylooking willow. He was a ringbearer, best friend to his gardener, samwise gamgee, and one of the three hobbits who sailed from middleearth to the. I think hermione is rather irritating in the books, ron less so, and harry about the same. The dwarves are described the dwarves who come to as having brightly coloured bilbos door have short beards and cloaks. The hobbit, the lord of the rings, and tolkien the one ring. Frodo in the bookfrodo in the movie science fiction. An example is during the scene at the ford of rivendell when frodo is being chased by the black riders. One of the greatest fantasy novel series of all time changed movies forever when it was. But on the other hand, bilbo fights goblins and gollum, along with smaug in the end. Tolkien divides the change in bilbo s character into the three major part of the book, prior to the quest, during the quest, and after the quest. The hobbit is a great book but i just love harry potter. Lord of the rings and the hobbit vs harry potter gamespot.
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the faq by clicking the link above. I include not only alterations to the books plot, but also book scenes that are not included in the films as well as new scenes written by the filmmakers. Bilbo bagginsharry potter works archive of our own. With a mum and dad like yours, what else would yeh be. The hobbit movies are the only films with more minutes of film than book pages. Evolution of harry potter games 20012020 by group m pro. Bilbo sighedknowing it would be hopeless to try and dissuade harry and instead ran after the giant snake as quickly as his little legs could take him.
In 1969 over 30 years after first publication, tolkien sold the film and. Bilbo s ring doesnt seem like a big deal until gandalf reconsiders what is happening. He was, and still is, tolkiens most renowned character for his leading role in the quest of the ring, in which he bore the one ring to mount doom, where it was destroyed. Lor consisted of three books each 300 to 400 pages long which resulted in a trilogy of 3 hourlong movies. Most of the dwarves dont have hats, and they dont greet him like the book describes.
In the world of harry potter, hedwig the owl was a trusty companion who delivered messages and generally helped the young wizard thrive. Bilbo baggins, the titular protagonist, is a respectable, reserved hobbita race resembling. In both the book and movie version of the hobbit bilbo baggins is first portrayed with a reluctant attitude towards adventure but gradually transitions into having. The desolation of smaug, however, the careful pacing of the first film seems to have gone out the hobbiton window, leaving behind a film that is, in parts, jawdroppingly spectacular seriously, my jaw actually dropped. Ron is one of my favourite characters in the book, such a recognizable teenager. Dwalin settled down and pulled a knife from his boot before he started to whittle at a log from next to the fire. Donate today and show your support for the archive. This is significant, for just as harry potter decides his own fate under the sorting hat when choosing gryffindor as his school house, bilbo finds.
Harry potter series book movie book movie voldemorts evil nature is. He doesnt actually accept it is the one ring until late. Harry potter series book movie book movie voldemorts evil nature is voldemorts only motivating attributed to him being a descendant slytherin. Bilbo put the ring into an envelope containing his will and left it for frodo on the mantlepiece. He worked for the british army for 12 years in the field of battlespace information management and developed a language used for the semantic modeling of dynamic information across a complex enterprise. The final hobbit film is an unprecedentedly gratuitous stretch of.
Well, before i say anything more detailed, id like to point something out. Adapting lotr vs adapting harry potter comedy film nerds. While there are some changes in sequence, the storyline is well aligned between the two sources. Prior to the quest, bilbo baggins was a conservative, respectable and stubborn hobbit who lead a rich and comfortable life stephanie web. But, hes hoping that being in the company of thirteen odd dwarves will help bilbo find some form of acceptance and, if bilbo s really lucky, family and love. Frodo baggins, son of drogo baggins, was a hobbit of the shire during the third age. The book clearly describes this part, and says how all the dwarves greeted bilbo, hung up their cloaks and hats on the hook, and came in. Why is the hobbit book better than its movie adaptation. Harry fights three headed dogs, deals with being lost in a whole new world,solves mysteries and has to fight this evil bad voldemort. Harry potter and the order of the phoenix duration. In the film, he is simply given it by gandalf after he finds it on the floor. Harry potters world in the original 7 books is mainly restricted to the castle, a section or so of.
Tolkiens book the fellowship of the ring and the peter jackson film screenplay of the same name are fairly easy to document because, in both the book and film, the story maintains a single thread from beginning to end. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 book vs. As gandalf drives his wagon of fireworks for bilbos party and singing the road goes ever on and. The movies brush lightly over a lot of details, and skip almost completely over my favourite character regulus black so. Battle stations p 51 mustang plane documentary duration. In the movie all of the dwarves had cloaks and hats when they showed up at bilbo s hats on the first night. Resident tolkienite anna klassen compares the film to the original novel, revealing 19 differences between the tolkien classic and the movie. Wrap up the books and movie with harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 send me an email. The book is pretty much always going to be better than the movie. He is a renowned character for his leading role in the quest for erebor, in which he helped the dwarves reclaim their homeland from smaug. A hobbit, by the name of frodo baggins, is given a gift from his cousin, bilbo baggins if you have heard of tolkiens prior novel, the hobbit, then you may have heard this name before. The harry potter movies do a better job at playing true to the moral of the stories. Harry lives with his uncle vernon and aunt petunia.
1366 1558 294 413 429 214 1487 83 710 521 1519 1198 466 828 1190 13 694 1356 1539 494 1258 1145 167 1316 1149 1483 1432 160 141 633 80 1092 1167 951 1308 90 39 960 1387 742 212